Trump lawyer Alina Habba scolded on ‘Evidence 101’ in tumultuous trial performance

Donald Trump’s attorney, Alina Habba, arrived at the federal courthouse in downtown Manhattan on Thursday dressed in all black with her hair pulled back in a tight bun – a noticeable deviation from her colourful, trendy outfits and typical hairstyle.

It was day three of the defamation trial between writer E Jean Carroll and Mr Trump, in which a jury is being asked to determine how much, if any, damages the former president owes Ms Carroll for defaming her in statements he made in 2019 denying he knew her or sexually assaulted her.

Last year, a jury found Mr Trump liable for sexual abuse and defaming Ms Carroll in statements he made in 2022.

So far the trial has been contentious. On Wednesday, Ms Habba was reprimanded multiple times by Judge Lewis Kaplan. 

Shortly after 9.30am on Thursday, Ms Habba took to the lectern to finish her cross-examination of Ms Carroll. Almost immediately her questioning resulted in a sidebar and sustained objections. That pattern continued most of the morning.

Ms Habba’s numerous attempts to enter old tweets into evidence were objected to and sustained. One of her questions to Ms Carroll was struck from the record. Judge Kaplan asked Ms Habba to “move on” multiple times and had to remind her to respect his rulings.

At one point, the judge interrupted Ms Habba’s questioning of Ms Carroll to direct her to be more clear.

“This is evidence 101,” he said exasperatedly.

Ms Habba was clearly frustrated with the number of sustained objections. At times, she shook her head, subtly lifted her hands in exasperation and at once let out an audible sigh.

Though Thursday’s trial contained less palpable tension between the defence and the judge (whether or not that has to do with the former president’s